Visit our other Restaurants



81219 OVERSEAS HIGHWAY, ISLAMORADA, FLORIDA | 305-664-2006

Dinner

Served 5pm – Close

Starters

Kobe Beef Sliders – $20
Ground Kobe Beef, Tomato Bacon Jam and Blue Cheese on Mini Pretzel Buns

Buffalo Cauliflower – $11
Corn Starch dusted Cauliflower tossed in Buffalo Sauce with Carrots and Celery

House Smoked Fish Dip – $14
Creamy Fish Dip, Creole Mustard, Capers, Red Onions and Crackers gf

Conch Fritters – $16
Remoulade Sauce and Lemon hedges

Skillet Cornbread – $9
Oven Baked with Maple Pecan Butter

Bang Bang Shrimp – $14
Crispy Shrimp tossed in Boom Boom Sauce, Grilled Fresh Lime and House Slaw

Small Plates

Lobster Mac n’ Cheese – Market
Florida and Maine Lobster with Cavatappi Pasta, Creamy Cheese Sauce topped with Parmesan and Truffle Bread Crumbs

Seared Sea Scallops – $26
Seared Scallops served on a Bed of Mixed Greens with a Cucumber and Mango Salsa finished with a Seafood Beurre Blanc gf

Jumbo Lump Maryland Style Crab Cake – $22
Jumbo Lump Crabmeat Maryland Style broiled to perfection with Creamy Slaw and Old Bay Remoulade

Beer Battered Fish Sliders – $17
Beer Battered Fresh Catch served on Toasted Slider Buns with Lettuce, Tomato and Avocado topped with a Cilantro Lime Aioli

Guy’s Favorite”
Conch Chowder gf 8/10
Turtle Chowder 8/10
Soup of the Day 8/10

Garden

Wedge Salad – $11
Iceberg Lettuce Wedges, Applewood Smoked Bacon, Crumbled Blue Cheese, Diced Tomatoes, and House Made Blue Cheese Dressing
gf

Grilled Chicken Cobb Salad – $16
Crisp Romaine, Diced Egg, Bacon, Cucumber, Tomato and Crumbled Blue Cheese
gf

Hearts of Palm – $12
Hearts of Palm, Cucumber, Grape Tomatoes, and Pickled Red Onion served over Spring Mix and Prosciutto with White Balsamic Dressing
gf

Beet Salad – $12
Herb Roasted Beets, Spinach, Crumbled Goat Cheese, Truffle Honey, House White Balsamic Dressing
gf

Chopped Caesar Salad – $12
Romaine Hearts, Toasted Focaccia Slices, Parmesan, White Anchovy
Add Chicken $4, Add Shrimp $6

Pecan Shrimp Salad – $16
Jumbo Pecan dusted Shrimp, Baby Greens, Candied Pecans, Feta Cheese, Sweet Cranberries, Strawberries and a White Balsamic Dressing

From the Heartland

*Classic Filet Mignon – 6 oz $38 | 8 oz $46
Hand-Cut served with Bearnaise Sauce, Garlic Mashed Potatoes and Vegetables du Jour

*14 oz USDA Prime Ribeye – $50
Red Wine Demi Glace, Roasted Red Potatoes and Asparagus

*12 oz Prime New York Strip Steak – $44
With Garlic Mashed Potatoes and Broccoli gf

Pasta

Chicken Madeira Pasta – $26
Grilled Chicken Thighs, Madeira Cream Sauce, Parmesan, Grape Tomato and Mushrooms with Cavatappi Pasta
Substitute Shrimp $8

Farmhouse Pasta – $21
Onion, Garlic, Mushrooms, Spinach, Grape Tomato with Spaghetti in a Wine Sauce topped with Fresh Burrata

From the Sea

Fresh Catch

Classics – $36
Picatta, Blackened, Seared, Onion Crusted

a la Roxie – Seared and topped with Crab, Tomato and Lemon Caper Beurre Blanc – $9

a la Sid – Seared then covered in a Maine Lobster, Orange and Butter Sauce – Market Price

Fresh Catch Preparations served over Jasmine Rice and Red Quinoa with Vegetables du Jour

Seared Sea Scallops – $51
With Diced Lobster, Applewood Smoked Bacon, Mushrooms, Wilted Spinach, Chablis, and Garlic Butter over Fettuccini

Fresh Hand-Cut Black Gulf Grouper – $44
Choice of Grilled, Blackened or Picatta Style served over Jasmine Rice and Red Quinoa with Vegetables du Jour

Classic Shrimp Scampi – $30
Garlic, Fresh Diced Tomato, Lemon Juice, White Wine and Cream over Pasta

Turtle Classics

Bacon Wrapped Love “Guy’s Favorite” – $26
Chef’s Signature Meatloaf stuffed with Mushrooms wrapped in Thick Cut Applewood Bacon and topped with Meatloaf Glaze served with Mashed Potatoes, Mushroom Gravy and Green Beans

Southern Smoked Shrimp and Grits – $24
Smoked Shrimp Andouille Sausage, Peppers and Onions perched on Creamy Grits in a Creamy Broth

Turtle BBQ
Limited Availability, See Menu Below

There is a $5.00 charge applied for split plates.

A la Carte – $6

  • Truffle Tater Tots
  • Mac n’ Cheese
  • Baby Vegetables gf
  • Jasmine Rice and Black Quinoa gf
  • Creamy Mashed Potatoes gf
  • Southern Collard Greens gf
  • Grilled Asparagus gf

Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.